Writing as Art vs Professional Writing
We know there are many unwritten rules to handcuff the writer, and it’s easy to confuse when and where these rules should be obeyed or broken. For professional writers in business or journalism, there are the obvious cases that must be satisfied. However, for the writer of fiction, the rules should be torched and never revisited.
In the latest edition of Writers Ask, (#45, Fall 2009, Glimmer Train Press) Shauna Singh Baldwin quotes a character from her novel, THE TIGER CLAW:
“An Artist cannot wait for permission, but must seize it.”
What better way to address the rules in fiction, because aren’t rules really about permission to write a certain way? The novelist has a responsibility to write as though no rules exist or ever did. A vacuum of self serving expression that cares nothing for screenplay, TV or structure must envelop the artist in a cocoon to shield them from the onslaught of language, grammar and convention. Without this, artistic expression is washed away and we’re left with the watered down milk toast that permeates pop culture.
To seize means to take by force, in defiance of protocol. Without this defiance, there is no art.
Categories: Novel Writing
Tagged: Art, Art of the Novel, Books, Fiction, Writing
Too many English majors and too many English professors ruin writing, especially the novel. The novel is an art form outside of mere language, beyond the comprehension of grammar, and in another realm from writing. It is about storytelling and prose, not writing. Writers work for magazines and newspapers and I can’t think of many that go on to write beautiful literature, they are two different skill sets.
The novel as an art form isn’t about following a formula that ends each chapter with a hook, or drama, or suspense, although they all have their place. It is about creating beauty with words, exposing ugliness, and raising questions rather than delivering answers.
If you looked at a list of Nobel Prize winning novelists, I doubt you’d find more English professors than any other background, I don’t think one has anything to do with the other. Unfortunately however, the world of English profs think they’re the only one’s qualified to teach the art of writing novels. I guess Woody Allen said it best, ‘Those who can’t do teach, and those who can’t teach, teach gym.’
When I get a crit that gives me no more insight than Elmore Leonard’s 10 rules, I ignore it, because I already know the rules and I didn’t care about them when I started, so why should I care about them now? I love it when a critter catches a typo, because God knows we all make them, but I want to know how the material strikes them, not if I broke a rule. I think people know that is how I crit their work, I crit from my gut. Like the moral philosopher Robert C. Solomon said, justice doesn’t come from due process or objective examination, it comes from the gut. When I read something I know how it makes me feel, and at that moment I think I might know what would make it better. I try not to candy coat it.
Categories: Novel Writing
Tagged: Art of the Novel, Books, Creative Writing, Fiction, The Fact of Fiction, Writing
Snap 2 of 3 from the Jaws of Jays
The Jack Wilson Terrier Ready for the Heat
What the Mariners need now is a new kind of winning streak. With Garret Olsen up for the start, he takes his three scoreless innings against the Ranger bats to the House of Nolan. Leaving records behind in Seattle, they’ll throw Vargas, Hernandez and Washburn to the Sun before air dropping in KC. Win or lose they’re coming home with a tan.
Categories: Wakamatsu in My Shoes
Tagged: Baseball, MLB, Seattle Mariners, Sports, Texas Rangers, Toronto Blue Jays
M’s Swept 31-6 at the Safe in 3 Games with the Tribe
Seattle Sports Media Screaming for Club to Sell
Bedard to the DL
With the trade deadline looming this week, Mariner fans are jumping ship like rats in a fire. With a record of 51-47 though, is there any reason to panic? Certainly the M’s offense showed a sever lack of pop on a weekend in which Seattle’s salt air had more lift than the Spruce Goose. Yet, isn’t that something we’ve known all along?
Nothing’s really changed from this weekend. The M’s have been rolling out a line-up of Ichiro, Gutierrez and 6 guys from Tacoma for the better half of this season. In doing so, they’ve improve their lot over these last five years dramatically. In fact, they are in no worse shape now than if they had turned the tables and swept the Indians instead. In either case, they would be trailing the Angels by a handful of games. The M’s have an opportunity right now to keep themselves in contention and settle the AL West in September, when it’s supposed to get settled.
Nobody ever won or lost a division in July, and the M’s won’t do it now either, unless they give up. Popular opinion says it’s time to sell Branyan and Washburn while their stock is high. These Shoes however, say to hold steady and don’t flinch. The greatest success comes from the ashes of disaster and the M’s need only do what we’ve been asking of them all along, add a couple of bats and keep fighting. This thing isn’t over yet.
Categories: Wakamatsu in My Shoes
Tagged: AL West, Baseball, Cleveland Indians, Erik Bedard, Franklin Gutierrez, Ichiro, Jarrod Washburn, Los Angeles Angels, MLB, Russell Branyan, Seattle Mariners, Sports, Tacoma Rainiers
M’s Visiting Record at 26-26 After Taking 2 of 3 from Tigers
So much for all the talk about the West being the weakest division in the AL. The lowly Seattle Mariners at third place have a 500 or better record against every team they’ve played in the AL East and Central with the exception of KC and NY and Chicago, each of which they have only played on the road. At 51-44, they would have a full 1 game lead over Detroit and Chicago in the Central.
For ever and a day us left coasters have had to listen ad nauseam to early season prognosticators talk about how weak the West is. And not just in Baseball, we get the same thing out here with our Seahawks too. How many teams from the NFC West have been to the Super Bowl in the last 10 years? And now how many from the so called dominant NFC East?
At 9-1 in their last 10 games, the Angels are heating up in a hurry and they don’t care who gets in their way. The Yankees, the Red Sox, so what? For all the talk about big markets and big budgets, neither team could get past the Rays last year. One thing is becoming evident as August looms, each AL division has three contenders fighting for a Pennant, and whatever happens it’s going to be a blast. Like most summers though, pitching depth will win out.
Categories: Wakamatsu in My Shoes
Tagged: American League, Baseball, Boston Red Sox, Chicago White Sox, Detroit Tigers, Kansas City Royals, Los Angeles Angels, MLB, New York Yankees, Seattle Mariners, Sports, Tampa Bay Rays
El Gato Grande K’s 8 in 7
Paul Bunyan Tied for AL Homer Lead
Skip work if you’re in Seattle, Jarrod Washburn takes his new and improved butt twist to the mound in Detroit today for a chance to win the series. In the top five among AL pitchers for ERA, Washburn may finally be maturing mentally and mechanically with his craft. Like Jamie Moyer and others that have found their game late, Washburn is proving that you don’t have to a young, hot prospect to light up the strike zone.
Look for Gutierrez in centerfield this morning. Getting him back on the horse at the scene of the crime is the best thing possible. He needs to see that scoreboard up close and personal again to assure us all that there won’t be any side effects from Tuesday night’s crash. With Detroit’s pitching and balanced offense, don’t be surprised if the road to the ALCS runs through the Motor City this October.
Categories: Wakamatsu in My Shoes
Tagged: Baseball, Detroit Tigers, Felix Hernandez, Franklin Gutierrez, Jamie Moyer, MLB, Russell Branyan, Seattle Mariners, Sports
the collective unconscious…
Fascinating Alfredo. The Earth may ultimately serve as our collectivity. But the question is how. How. How? How! How did we become collective? What is the link, where is the chain? Who did this to us? Why did it happen this way? Is there a way we can change? Does it matter? When did it all begin?
Categories: Novel Writing
Tagged: Books, Fiction, Novels, Philosophy, the collective unconscious, Writing